.
Feedback

Chevron Fire Updates: Swelling Claims, Incorrect Reports

The impacts of Monday's large Chevron refinery fire continue to make themselves felt with claims and hospital visits climbing into the thousands as scam artists enter the picture and the news media ask hard questions.

Editor's note: A Bay City News story below reports the thousands of claims filed with Chevron by residents for medical and other expenses caused by the big refinery fire Monday night, as well as 5,763 people who had sought treatment at local emergency rooms as of noon Friday.

Meanwhile, a San Francisco Chronicle article under a front-page banner headline, "Severity of leak misjudged?", questioned whether Chevron officials took appropriate action when they first discovered the hydrocarbon leak that caused the fire. "The company has been criticized for running the plant for two hours Monday afternoon after a worker first spotted the leak," the Chronicle reported.

At the same time, reports by the Bay Area Quality Management District that air samples during the fire showed no harmful levels of toxic residues were not entirely accurate, according to the Associated Press and Contra Costa Times. Contra Costa Times columnist Daniel Borenstein also reported that air sampling of particulates by the air district was conducted about three miles away and wasn't done until midnight, nearly six hours after the fire broke out and after the shelter-in-place order was lifted.

In related news, Contra Costa County Supervisor John Gioia issued a warning against a scam reported by the county district attorney's office in which someone is providing false claim forms to residents and asking them to provide confidential information. Those who wish to file claims should do so directly by calling the 24-hour Chevron claims line at 866-260-7881 or by visiting the Chevron claims office at 598 Nevin Ave. in Richmond.

The City of Richmond has established a "Chevron Refinery Fire" webpage with a variety of information and links about the fire and its aftermath.

Thousands filing claims

By Bay City News Service

A long line of people formed around a help center that opened today at the Nevin Community Center in Richmond as residents waited to file liability claims against Chevron for costs related to Monday's fire at the oil company's refinery in the city.

By 3 p.m., 347 people had filed claims at the center seeking reimbursement for medical care, property damage and lost wages related to the fire, which sent thick smoke and soot throughout Bay Area communities and prompted a shelter-in-place warning for residents in Richmond, North Richmond and San Pablo.

That number is in addition to the 3,859 people who have filed a claim through a hot line set up by Chevron, according to company spokeswoman Katie Winter, who helped people check in today.

The center will be open from 8 a.m. to noon on Saturday and from 9 a.m. to 7 p.m. all next week. Insurance services company Crawford and Co. is handling the claims.

On the heels of the fire that burned for five hours Monday night, Chevron has pledged to reimburse all "reasonable" claims.

By noon today, 5,763 people had been treated and released at local emergency rooms with complaints of symptoms related to the blaze, Contra Costa Health Services spokeswoman Katie Fowler said.

While Chevron representatives said they did not have a breakdown of the types of costs the claims filed so far have sought to reimburse, spokeswoman Melissa Ritchie said most are for out-of-pocket health care, property damage and lost earnings.

This afternoon, area residents waited in the line snaking around the community center to file their claims, some with hospital receipts and prescriptions in hand.

Paul Stewart, 52, said he's struggled with Asthma for years, but never as badly as he has after Monday's fire, which he said caused him to wait eight hours before being seen in the crowded emergency room at Doctor's Medical Center in San Pablo earlier this week.

"It made it so I couldn't breathe at all," he said. "I'm taking a lot more medicine than I ever have."

The lifelong Richmond resident said he expects to be reimbursed, if only minimally, by Chevron, but added that he would be careful not to sign anything that might prevent him from filing a legal complaint against the oil giant later.

"These people should not sign their rights off," he said, glancing at the line of people front of him.

Chevron representatives today said the company is not asking those who file liability claims to give up their right to a lawsuit.

Richmond resident Oscar Hoyos, 46, said he's just as concerned with seeing Chevron take responsibility for its actions than he is with getting his money back for out-of-pocket medical costs.

"It's not only about the money, it's about responsibilities," he said.

Hoyos, who was outdoors working construction in Richmond when the fire started, said he headed to Kaiser Richmond on Tuesday when he started experiencing eye irritation and stomach problems.

"That's what we are worried about ... some symptoms come with time," he noted.

While waiting in line, Hoyos chatted with a San Pablo woman about her experience during and after the refinery fire.

The woman, a 53-year-old former nurse's assistant named Verna who declined to give her last name, said she hasn't suffered symptoms related to the fire but is worried about the long-term health effects and came to the center to get answers.

"Smoke inhalation can kill you - and that stuff is still in the air," she said.

The Bay Area Air Quality Management District corrected its original assessment Thursday of that there were no detectable pollutants from the fire above normal levels. The district now says air samples after the fire revealed levels of a pollutant called acrolein that are above the federally recommended exposure limit.

Particulate matter, the most harmful pollutants released during the fire, according to Contra Costa County Health officials, is likely what has caused respiratory illness, irritation, headaches and other symptoms reported by residents.

----------------------------------------------------------

See more of Patch's Chevron fire coverage:

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from El Cerrito Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Loading comments ...
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
gretchen davidson May 21, 2013 at 12:00 pm
Yes I would love to take one off of your hands. Please email me at gretchen_davidson@yahoo.com toRead More discuss off board.
Elaine Binger May 20, 2013 at 07:30 am
Gretchen, I have several different sizes of rakes. If you want to come see them, let me know throughRead More Patch. Elaine
gretchen davidson May 16, 2013 at 02:50 pm
Was that what i heard in the middle of the night on Wednesday? I thought i was dreaming. It soundedRead More like some sort of loudspeaker.
Robin M. Blind May 15, 2013 at 09:16 pm
Gee...are you SURE that alarm IS coming from Portola Middle School? Um...I suppose that you ARERead More sure! Yes...it IS turbo-annoying but I had assumed that it was some stupid car alarm.
Bonnie MacKenzie May 11, 2013 at 11:55 am
Can you please be more specific about the nature of the problem for those of us who do not live inRead More the neighborhood?
John Stashik April 25, 2013 at 09:03 pm
Thanks for the press release, err... story. Now how about El Cerrito news? The Patch staff is lazy.
Dorothy Coakley April 8, 2013 at 08:02 pm
Good thought, Julian.
Julian April 8, 2013 at 11:32 am
I've spoken with him, he is educated, intelligent and articulate. He is also angry and sometimesRead More irrational. I dont know his story but his "street art" stands on its own legs. If you would like to help him, and yourself, buy and enjoy his art.
Rita Wilson April 7, 2013 at 09:51 pm
A neighbor of mine on Colusa tried to give him food when he was on Colusa, but he refused, so IRead More never tried. Dorothy, is that the shelter near the Berkeley Historical Society/Veteran's Building? Perhaps he would need a ride to it. Perhaps he's concerned about leaving his things there if he can't be there during the day. I'm afraid I don't know enough about it.
Dorothy Coakley March 27, 2013 at 04:36 pm
I did mention that I'm donating 10% of my royalties for "Midnight" to the EC's Open SpaceRead More fund, didn't I? I'm a Down-home Ten Percenter.
Dorothy Coakley March 27, 2013 at 04:31 pm
Lucy, I like the idea in principal, but in reality I think it would just give ECPD more work to do.Read More "People hanging out" doesn't necessarily translate to a friendly,fun-filled, folksy kind of environment. It *can* mean quite the reverse. "Midnight On the Ohlone" sounds like a new recording. Something like "I left my little babeeeeee, down by the tracks....and now I want her back....she's a needle in the haaaaaaay staaaaack...' Arhoolie awaits.
Lucy March 27, 2013 at 12:58 pm
What a great idea for pocket parks!!! I am all for them. Instead of spening a big amount on oneRead More (which we don't have space anyway), I would like to see many mini parks of $20,000 along the Bart tracks. With more visibility and people hanging out, it would make Bart paths safer too, especially the one around fairmont park. Really mini pocket parks just needs some play structures, benches and tables there.